Handsome Devil BBQ PK

About Us

Some restaurants are open seven days a week and taste like it. Handsome Devil BBQ is open four days a week and every bite proves why that matters. Thursday through Sunday, 26 Academy Street in Poughkeepsie becomes the kind of place people plan their weekend around, the kind of place that earns a 4.4-star rating from 173 reviews and inspires customers to drive up from New York City not once, but twice in the same trip.

The smoke does the talking here. Brisket gets the low-and-slow treatment until it's tender enough to pull apart with a fork but still holds that perfect bark on the outside. The jalapeño cheddar link has its own fan club. Pulled pork, ribs, collard greens, potato salad, chili, every item on the menu is made with the same obsessive attention that turns first-time customers into regulars who can recite their order before they reach the counter.

The staff matches the food. Reviewers mention them by name, call them amazing, and mean it. This is a small operation running at full throttle four days a week, and that focus shows in every carefully wrapped takeout order and every generous portion that lands on the table.

What We Offer

Handsome Devil BBQ runs a tight, focused menu built around wood-smoked meats and the sides that belong beside them. The brisket is the anchor, drawing regulars and road-trippers alike, but the full spread gives you plenty of reasons to order more than you planned.

Signature smoked meats include brisket, pulled pork, ribs, and the jalapeño cheddar link that gets mentioned in nearly every glowing review. On the sides, collard greens, potato salad, and chili round out a plate the right way. Portions are generous, packaging is careful, and takeout orders arrive in the same condition as anything eaten in-house.

Dine in or carry out, the experience holds up. The restaurant is open Thursday through Sunday, 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM. If you're planning a group order or a weekend pickup, arriving early in the afternoon is your best bet before the most popular cuts sell out.

Why Choose Us

Slow-smoked brisket and ribs that earned a 4.4-star rating across 173 genuine customer reviews.

Generous portions served by a staff that customers consistently call out by name for being exceptional.

A focused four-day-a-week schedule means every item is made fresh, never stretched thin across a full week.

Jalapeño cheddar links and pulled pork that have driven customers up from New York City more than once.

Careful takeout packaging so your order arrives at home in the same great shape it left the kitchen.

A local Poughkeepsie institution on Academy Street with the kind of loyal following most restaurants spend years chasing.

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

⭐ Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

6 months ago

"I had a great takeout experience with my order of brisket (unfortunately I started eating before remembering to take a photo), collared greens, chili, and ribs! The orders were carefully wrapped in foil and by friendly staff for my long drive back to NYC. The brisket was tender and great with their sauce. The ribs were meaty and flavorful. I would definitely consider stopping by again."

— James Chin

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

a year ago

"Best BBQ I've ever had. Would give it 120 out of 100 for the great taste and amazing staff. Generous portions, perfectly smoked flavor and texture. Drove from NYC just to visit the place twice and each time was excellent! Loved the brisket, ribs, sausages, collard greens, mac-cheese, and corn bread. Hoping to try all the items on the menu!"

— Joe Zou

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

a month ago

"Handsome Devil BBQ is by far my favorite BBQ spot. I love the brisket, jalapeño cheddar link, pulled pork, potato salad, and collards. It's all slammin'. The portions are generous, and the staff is the sweetest. The only thing I'd love to see added is sweet tea. Other than that, it can't be beat."

— Stalene Hall

⭐⭐

a year ago

"Ordered a lot of food as we were in the mood for some classic American BBQ as it was 65° in early April. Honestly, the food was fine and the service was astoundingly terrible. Employees will come to your table with a literal blow torch and “crisp” up your meat and Mac and cheese. It doesn’t do anything so it’s just for show really. Pointless and weird. The lady at the register looked and spoke to us like she didn’t care that we were here or even wanted to work there. The food however, after all this, was just fine. The highlights were the collard greens and pulled pork. Did I even mention they were out of brisket as well? Unfortunate. The ribs were also good. Coleslaw was nice and tangy, no mayo based. Cornbread was super moist and flavorful Everything else was forgettable. Baked beans were mushy, Mac and cheese was okay. Never really been to PK before but this part of downtown felt a bit rough so lock ya doors"

— Patrick No

⭐⭐⭐⭐

10 months ago

"4 because we like the mac and cheese. We had take out, pulled pork, ugh so much fat, we must of got end piece. Brisket was dry and the ribs were ok really not what we expected. The manager was informative because I was trying food for a future party. I would like to try the other restaurant in newburg. Make sure if you are take out that u have food on plastic the grease gets all over! Seeps through paper bag."

— Lisa Cross

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the hours at Handsome Devil BBQ?

The restaurant is open Thursday through Sunday, 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM. It is closed Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday.

Where is Handsome Devil BBQ located?

You'll find them at 26 Academy Street in Poughkeepsie, NY 12601. Street parking is available in the surrounding area.

Do they offer takeout?

Yes. Takeout is a big part of how Handsome Devil operates, and reviewers specifically praise how carefully orders are wrapped and packaged for the trip home.

What are the most popular menu items?

The brisket is the runaway favorite, but the jalapeño cheddar link, pulled pork, ribs, collard greens, and potato salad all have dedicated fans. If you're going for the first time, ordering a mix is the move.

Should I call ahead or place an order in advance?

Given how popular certain cuts get later in the day, arriving earlier in the afternoon or checking their website at handsomedevilllc.com for any ordering options is a smart play, especially on weekends.

Is Handsome Devil BBQ worth the drive from New York City?

Multiple reviewers have made the trip from NYC specifically for the BBQ, with at least one returning twice in the same visit window. The consensus: absolutely worth it.

How does the portion size compare to typical BBQ spots?

Generous is the word that comes up over and over in reviews. Customers consistently note that the portions exceed expectations, which adds real value to every order.